Cost Comparison: Cabinet Refacing vs. New Cabinets – Which is Right for You?

Upgrading kitchen cabinets instantly transforms your space, but choosing between cabinet refacing and new cabinets can be tricky.

If you want a fresh look without breaking the bank, refacing might be the way to go. But if your cabinets are damaged, outdated, or poorly designed, replacing them could be the smarter investment.

This guide breaks down the cost differences, pros and cons, and long-term value of each option. By the end, you’ll know exactly which choice fits your budget, style, and home goals.

Understanding Cabinet Refacing and New Cabinets

Choosing between cabinet refacing and new cabinets starts with knowing what each option really involves. Both can give your kitchen a fresh look, but they differ in cost, process, and long-term benefits.

What Is Cabinet Refacing?

Cabinet refacing keeps your existing cabinet boxes while updating their appearance. Here’s how it works:

• Old doors and drawer fronts get replaced with new ones.

• Veneer or laminate covers the cabinet frames to match the new style.

• New hardware (handles, knobs, hinges) gets installed for a fresh look.

Refacing works best when your cabinets are structurally sound but need an update. It’s a faster, more affordable way to refresh your kitchen without a full remodel.

What Is Cabinet Replacement?

Replacing cabinets means removing the old ones and installing brand-new ones. You get a completely new layout, style, and storage options.

This process involves:

• Tearing out the existing cabinets

• Installing brand-new cabinets (custom, semi-custom, or stock)

• Adjusting plumbing or electrical work if needed

New cabinets make sense if your current ones are damaged, outdated, or don’t fit your kitchen’s layout anymore. While it costs more than refacing, it gives you full control over design, storage, and durability.

Cost Breakdown: Cabinet Refacing vs. New Cabinets

Budget plays a huge role in deciding between cabinet refacing and replacement. While refacing typically costs less, it’s important to break down where your money goes and what you’re really paying for.

Upfront Costs

The biggest difference between refacing and replacing cabinets is the initial price tag.

• Cabinet refacing costs anywhere from $4,000 to $9,000 for an average-sized kitchen.

• New cabinets cost between $8,000 and $25,000, depending on the materials and customization.

• Stock cabinets (pre-made, lower cost) range from $100 to $300 per linear foot.

• Custom cabinets (built specifically for your space) start at $500 per linear foot and up.

Refacing costs about 50% less than full replacement, making it a budget-friendly way to upgrade without gutting your kitchen.

Long-Term Value

While refacing saves money upfront, new cabinets may offer better long-term value. Here’s why:

• New cabinets last longer—high-quality replacements can last 20 to 50 years, while refaced cabinets may last 10 to 20 years.

• Customization adds storage and function, increasing home value.

• Cabinet quality matters—if your current cabinets are cheap or damaged, refacing might not be worth it.

Hidden Costs

Many homeowners focus on material and installation costs, but other expenses can add up:

• Structural repairs – If your existing cabinets have water damage, warping, or mold, refacing may not be an option.

• Hardware and accessories – Upgrading to soft-close hinges, drawer organizers, or glass panels adds to the total cost.

• Plumbing and electrical work – Replacing cabinets could require moving pipes or outlets, increasing labor costs.

While refacing avoids major renovations, new cabinets may require additional work, leading to higher overall costs.

Factors That Influence Cost Differences

Several factors affect the total price of cabinet refacing and replacement. Understanding these can help you make a more cost-effective decision.

Size of the Kitchen or Cabinetry Area

The more cabinets you have, the higher the cost—whether you’re refacing or replacing. Larger kitchens require:

• More materials (wood, laminate, veneer, etc.)

• More labor hours for installation

• Higher hardware costs (hinges, handles, knobs)

Smaller kitchens naturally cost less, but even a small space with high-end materials can get expensive.

Material Choices

The type of materials you choose plays a huge role in the price:

• Refacing materials:

  • Laminate veneer – Most affordable, but less durable ($1,000–$3,000).

  • Wood veneer – Mid-range cost, offers a real wood look ($2,500–$6,000).

  • Rigid Thermofoil (RTF) – Durable and moisture-resistant, often used for modern kitchens ($3,000–$7,000).

• Replacement materials:

  • Stock cabinets – Pre-made, limited styles, affordable ($100–$300 per linear foot).

  • Semi-custom cabinets – More design flexibility, mid-range ($150–$650 per linear foot).

  • Custom cabinets – Fully personalized, most expensive ($500+ per linear foot).

If you want high-end materials, refacing won’t save much compared to replacement.

Customization vs. Stock Options

If you’re okay with a standard look, refacing or stock cabinets will keep costs down. But if you want:

• New cabinet layouts

• Built-in storage solutions (pull-out shelves, spice racks)

• Glass panels or specialty doors

…then replacement is the better choice. Customization always adds cost but improves functionality and home value.

DIY vs. Professional Installation

Some homeowners try to DIY cabinet refacing, but mistakes can lead to visible seams, peeling veneer, or improper door alignment.

• DIY refacing kits cost around $500–$2,500, but require skill and time.

• Professional refacing costs $4,000–$9,000, but ensures flawless results.

• Cabinet replacement requires professionals for removal, installation, and possible plumbing/electrical work.

While DIY saves money upfront, professional work ensures quality, durability, and a higher home resale value.

Pros and Cons of Each Option

Both cabinet refacing and cabinet replacement have pros and cons. The best choice depends on your budget, kitchen condition, and long-term goals.

Cabinet Refacing: Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Lower cost – Typically 50% less than full replacement.

• Faster process – Most jobs take 3 to 5 days, compared to weeks for a full remodel.

• Less disruption – No need to tear out existing cabinets or modify plumbing or electrical work.

• Eco-friendly – Reduces waste by reusing cabinet frames.

Cons:

• Limited design changes – Layout stays the same; no extra storage or functionality.

• Doesn’t fix structural issues – If cabinets are warped or damaged, refacing won’t solve the problem.

• Shorter lifespan – Refaced cabinets last 10 to 20 years, compared to 20+ years for new cabinets.

New Cabinets: Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Complete customization – Choose any layout, material, and storage solution.

• Higher durability – High-quality cabinets last decades with proper care.

• Increases home value – A full kitchen remodel has one of the highest ROIs for resale.

• Fixes underlying issues – Ideal for old, damaged, or outdated cabinetry.

Cons:

• Higher cost – Can be twice the price of refacing, depending on materials and design.

• Longer installation – Takes weeks instead of days, with possible kitchen downtime.

• Potential hidden costs – Plumbing, electrical, and structural changes add to the final price.

If budget and timeline are your top concerns, refacing is a solid option. But if you want a long-term investment with more design freedom, replacing makes more sense.

When to Choose Refacing vs. Replacing

Not sure whether to reface or replace your cabinets? The right choice depends on your kitchen’s condition, your goals, and your budget. Here’s how to decide.

When to Choose Cabinet Refacing

Refacing works best when:

• Your cabinets are in good shape. If the frames and structure are solid, refacing can give them a fresh look without a full replacement.

• You like your current layout. Refacing doesn’t change the placement of cabinets, so it’s ideal if you’re happy with the existing setup.

• You want a cost-effective update. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly way to refresh your kitchen, refacing costs about 50% less than new cabinets.

• You need a faster renovation. Refacing takes 3 to 5 days, while replacement can take weeks.

• You want an eco-friendly option. Keeping your cabinet boxes reduces waste and avoids unnecessary demolition.

When to Choose Cabinet Replacement

Replacing cabinets is the better option when:

• Your cabinets are damaged. If they have water damage, mold, warping, or structural issues, replacing them is the only way to fix the problem.

• You want a new layout. If your kitchen lacks storage, has an inefficient layout, or feels outdated, new cabinets let you customize your space.

• You’re planning a full remodel. If you’re upgrading countertops, floors, or appliances, replacing cabinets ensures everything fits seamlessly.

• You want a long-term investment. New cabinets last 20+ years and increase home value, making them a better choice for resale.

• You need more customization. Built-in storage, soft-close drawers, glass doors, and specialty finishes aren’t possible with refacing.

If your goal is a quick, affordable refresh, refacing makes sense. But if you need a complete transformation with better durability, investing in new cabinets is worth it.

Home Value & ROI Considerations

Cabinet upgrades aren’t just about aesthetics—they also impact home value and return on investment (ROI). If you plan to sell your home in the future, knowing which option adds more value can help you make the right decision.

How Cabinet Refacing Affects Home Value

Refacing gives your kitchen a fresh, modern look at a lower cost, making it appealing to potential buyers. However, it doesn’t increase home value as much as new cabinets.

• ROI: 60% to 75% – A well-done refacing job can still improve your kitchen’s appeal and help sell your home faster.

• Good for cost-conscious sellers – If you want to refresh your kitchen without a full remodel, refacing is a budget-friendly way to boost resale potential.

• Best for homes with solid cabinetry – If your cabinet frames are in great condition, refacing can be a smart way to modernize your space without overspending.

How New Cabinets Affect Home Value

New cabinets offer the highest ROI because they improve functionality, durability, and design flexibility. If your kitchen looks outdated or lacks storage, new cabinets can make a big difference.

• ROI: 70% to 100% – Depending on the quality of materials and craftsmanship, new cabinets can fully pay off when you sell your home.

• Increases buyer appeal – Kitchens are a major selling point, and brand-new cabinets attract more buyers than refaced ones.

• Best for full remodels – If you’re already investing in new countertops, flooring, or appliances, new cabinets ensure a cohesive, high-end look.

Which Option Offers the Best ROI?

• If you’re selling soon → Refacing can refresh your kitchen without overspending.

• If you’re remodeling for long-term use → New cabinets provide better durability and higher resale value.

• If your cabinets are in bad shape → Buyers prefer quality, so replacing them prevents low-ball offers.

While both options improve your kitchen’s value, new cabinets have a stronger impact on resale price and buyer interest.

Making the Right Decision for Your Budget

Choosing between cabinet refacing and new cabinets comes down to your budget, kitchen needs, and long-term goals. Before making a decision, ask yourself these key questions.

Questions to Ask Before Deciding

1. What is my budget?

   • If you want to keep costs low, refacing is the more affordable option.

   • If you can invest more, new cabinets offer greater long-term value.

2. Are my current cabinets structurally sound?

   • If your cabinets are in good condition, refacing can give them a new look without replacement.

   • If they are damaged, warped, or outdated, replacing them is the smarter choice.

3. Do I need more storage or a new layout?

   • If your current cabinets work well, refacing is a cost-effective refresh.

   • If your kitchen lacks functionality, replacing them lets you customize the space.

4. How long do I plan to stay in my home?

   • If you plan to sell soon, refacing improves kitchen appeal without a huge investment.

   • If you’ll be living in your home for 10+ years, new cabinets are a better long-term investment.

5. How much time do I have for renovations?

   • If you need a quick update, refacing takes 3 to 5 days.

   • If you’re okay with a longer project, new cabinets may take weeks but offer more customization.

Budgeting Tips for Cost-Effective Cabinet Upgrades

• Compare multiple quotes – Whether you choose refacing or replacement, getting quotes from different contractors ensures you get the best deal.

• Prioritize quality materials – Spending a little more on durable materials will save money in the long run.

• Consider semi-custom cabinets – If you’re replacing, semi-custom cabinets offer a balance between affordability and design flexibility.

• Refinish or repaint instead of refacing – If your cabinets are solid wood, painting or refinishing could be an even cheaper alternative.

By weighing these factors, you can choose the best option for your budget and kitchen goals.

Conclusion & Call to Action

Choosing between cabinet refacing and new cabinets comes down to your budget, kitchen needs, and long-term plans. If you want a cost-effective refresh, refacing is a great way to update your kitchen without a full remodel. But if your cabinets are damaged, outdated, or inefficient, replacing them provides better durability, customization, and resale value. No matter which option you choose, investing in your kitchen enhances functionality and boosts home appeal.

If you're ready to upgrade your kitchen, JNF Remodeling Services LLC offers cabinet refacing, cabinet installation, and full kitchen remodeling services in Burleson, Dallas, and Fort Worth, TX. With expert craftsmanship and attention to detail, we help homeowners create beautiful, functional spaces that match their vision. Contact JNF Remodeling Services LLC today to schedule a consultation and start transforming your home.

FAQs About Cabinet Refacing vs. New Cabinets

1. Is cabinet refacing worth it, or should I just replace my cabinets?

Cabinet refacing is worth it if your existing cabinets are structurally sound and you want a cost-effective refresh. It gives your kitchen a new look at about half the cost of new cabinets. However, if your cabinets are damaged, outdated, or don’t meet your storage needs, replacing them is a better long-term investment.

2. How long does cabinet refacing take compared to cabinet replacement?

Cabinet refacing typically takes 3 to 5 days, while full cabinet replacement can take several weeks depending on the complexity of the installation. If you're looking for a quick and less disruptive upgrade, refacing is the better option.

3. Does cabinet refacing look as good as new cabinets?

Yes, when done professionally, refacing can look just as good as new cabinets because the doors and drawer fronts are completely replaced. The cabinet frames are covered with a matching veneer or laminate, making them look brand new. However, it won’t change the layout or storage capacity like a full replacement would.

4. How much money can I save by refacing instead of replacing?

On average, refacing costs 50% less than cabinet replacement. While a full cabinet replacement can range from $8,000 to $25,000, refacing typically costs $4,000 to $9,000, depending on materials and kitchen size.

5. How long do refaced cabinets last?

With proper care, refaced cabinets can last 10 to 20 years. The durability depends on the materials used and the quality of the work. If done professionally, refaced cabinets can withstand daily wear and tear just like new cabinets.

6. Can I add new cabinets when refacing, or do I have to keep my existing layout?

Cabinet refacing does not change the layout, but you can add new cabinets separately to expand storage. However, if you need a completely new layout, replacing your cabinets is the better choice.

7. Is cabinet refacing a good idea for resale value?

Yes, cabinet refacing improves the appearance of your kitchen, making it more attractive to buyers. It offers a 60-75% ROI, making it a good investment if you're selling soon. However, new cabinets offer a higher resale value because they improve storage, functionality, and durability.

8. Can I reface my cabinets myself, or should I hire a professional?

DIY cabinet refacing is possible, but it requires precise measuring, cutting, and veneer application. Mistakes can lead to peeling edges, misaligned doors, or a poor finish. Hiring a professional ensures a flawless, long-lasting result.

9. What’s the difference between refacing and refinishing cabinets?

• Refacing replaces the cabinet doors, drawer fronts, and applies a new veneer to the cabinet boxes.

• Refinishing involves sanding and repainting or staining the existing cabinet doors without replacing them.

Refacing provides a more dramatic transformation, while refinishing is a lower-cost option for cabinets that just need a fresh coat of paint.

10. Who should I call for professional cabinet refacing or replacement?

For expert cabinet refacing, cabinet installation, and kitchen remodeling in Burleson, Dallas, and Fort Worth, TX, contact JNF Remodeling Services LLC. Their team specializes in high-quality craftsmanship and custom solutions to help homeowners achieve their dream kitchen.